Foodpharmacy Blog - Organic health products, herbs and superfoods

Organic Eyeliner: Best Natural Products

L.A. Girl, Ultimate Eye, Intense Stay Auto Eyeliner, Neverending Navy, 0.01 oz (0.35 g)

$4.20

After uncapping the eyeliner, i could see that the tip of the pen was covered in promising shiny ink. Both eye color and the shape of your eyes should impact your choice of eyeliner. It also comes with an attached smudger which will give you the perfect smoky eyes. Many customers reported that this eyeliner was extremely smooth and easy to apply. My absolute all time favorite eyeliner is chanel le crayon kohl in noir because it’s richly pigmented and glides on nicely. If you choose a pencil eyeliner, you should also ensure that it has a sharpener on it that actually works. Reading eye-liner reviews, it seems that the same eyeliner performs very differently on different people, even aside from how they want to use it. The uz eye opening liner is now a staple in my makeup bag because with it’s paint brush applicator i can create a bright colorful look with just a flick of the wrist. The other side has a very fine tip for defining the rest of the eye with precision. There are some reports that the small, plastic insert that prevents too much liquid eyeliner from covering the brush has a tendency to break. You gently dip the stamp into the little pot of eyeliner ink, then press firm…


Rimmel London, Exaggerate Eye Definer, 212 Rich Brown, 0.009 oz (.28 g)

$3.70

A long-wearing, waterproof eye pencil that pairs ultra-creamy glide with instant color intensity. The rimmel exaggerate eye definer goes on smooth and produces a deep color. Most eyeliners, waterproof or otherwise, only come in a handful of basic shades. The users say that the ysl couture kajal eye pencil does everything that it promises to do. It even hangs on when i wear glitter eyeshadows that tend to make the corners of my eyes water a bit and does not end up looking crazy after a few hours. If you find yourself scrubbing your face raw to remove stubborn makeup, we recommend either switching to a different eyeliner, or consider using a stronger makeup remover. The creamy eyeliner glides on comfortably with foolproof precision to create customizable eye definition. For a naturally defined look, gently pull up the eyelid and line the upper rim as if you were filling in between the eyelashes. In the end, we found a dream team of assorted pencil, liquid, and gel eyeliners that stood up through long workdays and misty weekends. To gently remove your eyeliner, lightly dab and rinse your eyes, making sure to moisturize after to prevent your skin from drying out. This pencil also co…


L’Oreal, Infallible Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner, 402 Grey, 0.034 fl oz (1 ml)

$6.70

Com considers this the absolute best pencil eyeliner on the market, thanks to easy application and long-lasting wear. The best part about this eyeliner has to be the precise tip of the felt tip applicator. It never ended up smearing or settling into the corners of my eyes. It’s a go-to item in everyone’s makeup bag, and there is no shortage of options out there (Take a quick trip to the drugstore beauty aisle and you will see what we mean) but finding the best formulas is no easy feat. Product bled into eye even after a desired amount of drying had occurred and after 2 hours or less, product was black smudge under both eyes! Glossier play colorslide is a gorgeous, long-lasting liner pencil available in an eye-catching line-up of colors. The best thing about this eyeliner is the angle at which the applicator is in. While we do love a good smokey eye, we wanted to make sure that our top picks kept the control in our hands. Perhaps the most famous waterproof eyeliner out there, stila’s stay all day formula does exactly what the name suggests, plus makes it easy to create flicks and swoops, even for newbies. After a long day of having a full face of makeup, i double cleansed my face…


Koji, Dolly Wink, Pencil Eyeliner, Brown, 1 Piece

$8.50

Nothing looks worse than smudged eyeliner. Do you have to wear eyeliner with mascara? After more than 100 collective hours researching eyeliners; considering more than 100 gels, pencils, and liquids; and testing more than 50, we have found the three best eyeliners in pencil, liquid, and gel: Stila smudge stick waterproof eyeliner pencil, revlon colorstay skinny liquid liner, and the bobbi brown long-wear gel eyeliner. This eyeliner set comes with 24 diverse colors which makes it an excellent value. Most of the time, eyeliners are black or brown, but there are also quite a few cases of blue, green, and even white eyeliner as well. The liner is formulated to glide easily across your skin and apply evenly, which eliminates many of the problems pencil eyeliners tend to have. The uz eye opening liner is now a staple in my makeup bag because with it’s paint brush applicator i can create a bright colorful look with just a flick of the wrist. I always do a thick winged liner and this stuff has never transferred onto my upper eyelid like some products do. If they had to pick one eyeliner to use for the rest of their lives, they would pick this one, and i would have to say that i complete…


L’Oreal, Pencil Perfect Self-Advancing Eyeliner, 190 Carbon Black, 0.01 oz (280 mg)

$6.70

So i did not realize when i volunteered to test-drive an eyeliner that it was a liquid eyeliner, but when this landed on my desk, i knew i did not have a choice. This highly concentrated eyeliner holds pigments in a clear gel base that is safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. Because of this, we treated pencil-format eyeliners as pencils even when they had gel in the name, because they still have more in common with pencils than actual gels. Overall, respondents prioritized an eyeliner that stays on over one that is easy to get off, so we gave endurance more weight than easy removal. The other side has a very fine tip for defining the rest of the eye with precision. If reviews reported that the pigmentation in an eyeliner was not dark or faded easily, we discarded it from consideration. Urban decay 24/7 glide-on eye pencil comes in a billion easy-to-blend shades for every style of makeup. If you find yourself scrubbing your face raw to remove stubborn makeup, we recommend either switching to a different eyeliner, or consider using a stronger makeup remover.


Wet n Wild, MegaLiner Liquid Eyeliner, Black, 0.12 fl oz (3.5 ml)

$3.00

This eyeliner really does live up to the hype, and i was able to create my ideal cat eye in one stroke, which never ever happens. It’s a go-to item in everyone’s makeup bag, and there is no shortage of options out there (Take a quick trip to the drugstore beauty aisle and you will see what we mean) but finding the best formulas is no easy feat. To bring out your eyes, pair with hello lashes clinically proven 5-in-1 mascara for a wide-eye look! Eyeliners are basically the mvp of eye makeup, and one wrong move can result in a slew of black marks ruining the flawless mug you spent nearly two hours creating. Because of it’s versatility, you can drill down the tip of this eyeliner to a blunt edge for a polished point or dull it on your hand for a softer smear. I am notoriously bad at eyeliner, which is really tragic because i love it so much. Maybe i will use the white liner with a matte pink eye shadow on my lower lash line and matte orange eye shadow in my inner corner, or i will use the bright baby blue liner with a pastel pink on the waterline and a shimmery purple eyeshadow in the inner corner. The liner truly stays where you put, no matter how hungry your eyelids are. However, …


Physicians Formula, Eye Booster, Ultra Fine Liquid Eyeliner with Lash Conditioning Serum, Deep Brown, 0.016 fl oz (0.5 ml)

$7.20

The demi-matte formula sets after application so it sticks to the waterline instead of rubbing off on your eyeballs throughout the day. Stila’s liquid eyeliner makes it a little easier, however, with it’s convenient design. It’s easy to apply and control, the color payoff is great, and it does not irritate my extremely sensitive, allergy prone eyes. Here are 15 eyeliners with highly pigmented formulas, reliable staying power, and soft shapes that work great for the waterline, tightlining, and even less-invasive, regular eye-lining if you have sensitive eyes. Our pencil sharpeners feature stainless steel blades that shape our makeup pencils into the perfect tip every time. While amaterasu eye makeups are waterproof, smudge-proof and sweat-proof, facial oil will shorten it’s wear; additionally, it can clog applicator tips. Black eyeliner eye makeup:The color is really bright black,natural and last a long time,make you have a black big eye makeup. Also, avon glimmerstick (For eyebrows) is very good, but the dark brown is more like auburn. For hooded eyes, the skin will hide loads of the wing. Between the precision felt tip liquid liner on one end and the easy-application gel crayon…


Laura Geller, Line-N-Define, Dual Dimensional Eyeliner, Liquid & Kohl Eyeliner, Black/Brown, 0.07 fl oz (2 ml) / 0.017 oz (0.5 g)

$13.70

If you wear makeup, the odds are that you regularly use eyeliner, especially if you wear mascara or eyeshadow. For most people who regularly wear make-up, eyeliner is necessary to complete the look. While the particular eyeliner we feature here is black, there are also brown and blue options that are designed exactly the same. This eyeliner began to dry within less than two weeks. Cat eyes are next to impossible to do on me (Even pro artists struggle with it), so i do not wear black eyeliner all that often anymore. No one wants to have to regularly re-apply their eyeliner throughout the day. One of my favorite looks to do with this liner is honestly a cat eye because it’s foolproof and the perfect solution for when i am running late and do not have time for a full eyeshadow look. This eyeliner goes on really smoothly and stays put through most of the day, with only a minimal amount of smudging throughout the day.


Jane Iredale, Eye Pencil, White, 0.04 oz (1.1 g)

$12.80

We recommend purchasing an eyeliner that is easy to use with a thin yet durable tip. As a liquid eyeliner and general beauty junkie, i can be very critical of new products but love trying them out. You should remove all of your makeup thoroughly before sleeping each day, and always avoid rubbing, tugging, or scrubbing your face. I fully admit that part of the problem is my lack of liquid eyeliner skill. The pencil was easy to use and i even used it on my waterline because i have small eyes and that stayed on all day as well. Simply use a q-tip dipped in makeup remover and try again, or use concealer to cover any small mistakes. While it does have a controlled and continuous flow, it is best utilized if you line your eye in pencil first, then use this product.


E.L.F, Lock On, Liner And Brow Cream, Light Brown, 0.19 oz (5.5 g)

$5.00

Which color in eyebrow pencil should i choose for my brows? No matter which one suits your brows best, christine says you should always take a step back after filling in the arch area of your brows. In addition, i hate getting up in the morning, my brows are the last step in my beauty routine, and i do them in under 15 seconds and rushed. Those with coarse, unruly brows will particularly benefit. The pencil is automatic so there is no need of sharpening also. I have 2 kids and they are at an age where they do a lot of colouring at school and at least once a week i have to sharpen their pencils which used to take a lot of time. Do you use eyebrow gel before or after you use an eyebrow pencil? I am going to use my brow palette at home and have my pencil in my cosmetic bag to use when i am out. The brow fillers that can be mistaken for your favorite felt-tipped liquid liner are prime choices for covering scar tissue or bald spots, madron says. Watch your inbox and get ready for the latest skincare and makeup product reviews from our team of experts.


L’Oreal, Voluminous Smoldering Eyeliner, 645 Black, 0.087 oz (2.48 g)

$6.70

Insanely easy to use, cheap, and lasts forever, both in quantity, but i can literally wear this stuff all day, sleep in it, and wake up and my cat eye still looks good. Blue eyeliner drawn right under the eyebrow? While it does have a controlled and continuous flow, it is best utilized if you line your eye in pencil first, then use this product. Contour kits can also help with a bold, makeup-heavy style. The users say that the ysl couture kajal eye pencil does everything that it promises to do. However, not all eyeliners are the same. Wet n wild’s megaliner is one of the first eyeliners i ever used. Use it to stamp the perfect wing at the outer corner of your eyes, then trace the line across your lid.


Angfa, Scalp-D Beaute, Pure Free Eyeliner, Black, 0.02 fl oz (0.57 ml)

$16.50

Another hooded tester said the pencil transferred to her upper lid, but that she loved the fine point on this eyeliner. The stila smudge stick waterproof eyeliner is the best pencil-format liner: The retractable crayon comes out in a thin column, goes on the softest and smoothest, and sets to a finish that lasted the longest of the eyeliners we tested. My go-to eyeliner used to be the kat von d tattoo liner, but this is my new favorite. Of course, you should also make sure the color the eyeliner produces is vibrant and rich. With the help of the loreal paris super slim liquid eyeliner, you can create precise and sleek eyeliner looks. In addition to getting input from experts, we trawled through dozens of websites, lists, and guides to give us the broadest possible perspective on how people use eyeliner and what they like their eyeliners to do. Expensive eyeliners are far more likely to have fanbases than cheapies. The last thing anyone needs after bumping into an ex, boss, or in-laws is to realize that your flawless morning eyeliner has transformed into raccoon eyes. From mascara to razors, we tested over 50 affordable makeup, skincare, and haircare products to find the eight be…


Physicians Formula, Eye Booster, Ultra Fine Liquid Eyeliner with Lash Conditioning Serum, Ultra Black, 0.016 fl oz (0.5 ml)

$7.20

Laura mercier’s kohl eye pencil comes in a myriad of jewel-toned shades, which is perfect when wanting to create colorful looks that really make eyes stand out. The supple oils and natural extracts in wander beauty mile high club volume and length mascara glide to the very tips of lashes, creating a glossy fan that flutters in your side view. Or if you prefer the more low-key look of an off-duty model, we recommend reaching for the best neutral cream winner, the supergoop shimmershade eyeshadow, for a subtle wash of color on your lids. Here are 15 eyeliners with highly pigmented formulas, reliable staying power, and soft shapes that work great for the waterline, tightlining, and even less-invasive, regular eye-lining if you have sensitive eyes. To create soft sexy definition, line eyes then buff in a bit of darker matte or satin shadow on top of liner to diffuse the line. Since i like my eyes to look bigger, i opted for just the upper lid line, though many people like to tightline their bottom lid as well. The scabbing and crusting was black, so it mostly blended in and just looked like glossy eyeliner unless you were up really close. Slowly build up the eyeshadow with a soft fl…


E.L.F, Cream Eyeliner, Black, 0.17 oz (4.7 g)

$4.20

An all natural eyeliner without the mess of sharpening before each use as the twist up application comes with a built in sharpener. Or if you prefer the more low-key look of an off-duty model, we recommend reaching for the best neutral cream winner, the supergoop shimmershade eyeshadow, for a subtle wash of color on your lids. Then i took my make up off and the flyliner had stained my eyes, with what looked like a faint tattoo of eyeliner wings for about two days even with me scrubbing it off and showering so i will not be using it again which is a shame because i have and love all other fenty beauty products. This eyeliner has been an all time favorite of mine for a while now due to the fact that it is highly pigmented, perfect for creating a dramatic look and never smudges off. Ask any beauty pro what makes an amazing liquid liner, and you will likely hear the same qualifications pop up time and time again. Most eyeliners, waterproof or otherwise, only come in a handful of basic shades. Loaded with lash-plumping peptides and conditioners, marc jacobs beauty velvet primer amplifies the effect of your mascara. Contains chamomile flower extract to soothe and protect the eyes. This eyeliner really does live up to the hype, and i was able to create my ideal cat eye in one stroke, which never ever happens.


Covergirl, Intensify Me! Liquid Eyeliner, 300 Intense Black, .03 oz (1 ml)

$7.20

What is even better is that i can do a cat eye in the morning before work, go out the same night, return home and the lines are still perfectly in place – no smudging. At night, i was able to remove it with eye makeup remover, although there were traces i had to clean up the next morning. The shiny finish of the eyeliner also paired perfectly with the iridescent glow of my eye shadow, which i appreciated. A lot of the users say that this has officially become their go-to drugstore eyeliner. Some people might also use it on the bottom eyelid, though you will be hard pressed to find a style that uses eyeliner on only the bottom lid. It also washes right off with face wash and water, which i appreciate because i hate having to bust out the eye makeup remover. Users say that they literally cannot live without this eyeliner. It is perfect for winged eyeliner and smoky eyes. Do we want a daring swipe of purple eyeliner or a sexy black cat eye?


L’Oreal, Infallible Mechanical Eyeliner, 581 Black Brown, .008 oz (240 mg)

$6.70

For most people who regularly wear make-up, eyeliner is necessary to complete the look. The liner is formulated to glide easily across your skin and apply evenly, which eliminates many of the problems pencil eyeliners tend to have. If this describes you, there is absolutely no reason to force yourself to wear eyeliner. This eyeliner began to dry within less than two weeks. To bring out your eyes, pair with hello lashes clinically proven 5-in-1 mascara for a wide-eye look! With that said, in all other areas, this liquid eyeliner is a wonderful choice. This eyeliner takes a very long time to dry out so choosing the bigger option should not cause you to waste any. The first day i tried it i was impressed, it lasted a good 24 hours but was easy to remove with makeup remover. Yellow eyeliner used to create a star on the side of rico’s face?


E.L.F, Cream Eyeliner, Coffee, 0.17 oz (4.7 g)

$4.20

Enriched with organic moisturizing ingredients like organic jojoba oil (Moisturize the skin), shea butter (Protect the skin) and vitamin e (Anti-aging) for smooth application to the eyelids. It also washes right off with face wash and water, which i appreciate because i hate having to bust out the eye makeup remover. This eco-conscious austrlian owned company company makes organic eye pencils in addition to their organic liquid eyeliner. Eyeliners have been used for centuries to create dramatic shapes and designs around the eye. 100% Agree it delivers an eye-opening effect. You gently dip the stamp into the little pot of eyeliner ink, then press firmly onto the ends of your eyes. There are more than 6,000 reviews of this popular eyeliner pencil on sephora, where the product holds a 4,3-star average out of 5, one pleased shopper summed up the words of many with her comment, i have been using this eyeliner for years. From queen cleopatra to modern icons like sophia loren and brigitte bardot, their signature smokey and cat-eyes could never be complete, or dare we say possible, without a high-quality eyeliner. Born from a relentless pursuit of product perfection, our mission is to c…


Wet n Wild, Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil, Taupe of the Mornin’, 0.04 oz (1.4 g)

$1.50

It is infused with eyelash growth serum and castor oil to help your eyes pop even after you take it off. After a long day of having a full face of makeup, i double cleansed my face and the eyeliner came right off with little difficulty. Just remember that less is more and to always remove your powder eyeliner at the end of the day to avoid buildup and strain on the extensions. Nothing looks worse than smudged eyeliner. Marc jacobs highliner gel eye crayon eyeliner is the creamiest, most pigmented and blendable pencil eyeliner you will ever use, available in a ton of colors and finishes. It’s time to say goodbye to smudged raccoon eyes and having to reapply at noon, and hello to these eyeliners that are colorful, cheap and long lasting. After trying this for the first time, i now understand why so many people love this eyeliner. Figuring out what eye makeup to wear is one of our biggest daily morning decisions (Along with deciding whether it’s a dark roast or an espresso day). Check out the latest eyeliner picks from the good housekeeping institute beauty lab and our makeup experts. They claim that because of the 35-degree angle of the eyeliner, their flicks and wings have never …


L’Oreal, Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner, 930 Black, 0.042 fl oz (1.2 g)

$6.70

After reviewing dozens of products, the maybelline eyestudio master precise all day liquid eyeliner makeup stood out to us as the best. However, this can also cause you to use too much eyeliner, so experiment to figure out what style works best for you. As a liquid eyeliner and general beauty junkie, i can be very critical of new products but love trying them out. There are thousands of eyeliners on the market, but we wanted to concentrate on the very best. Cat eyes are next to impossible to do on me (Even pro artists struggle with it), so i do not wear black eyeliner all that often anymore. Everyone has their preference for what makes the perfect eyeliner, but any decent liner should be strongly pigmented and transfer-resistant. Plus, it is also waterproof but can be removed with a makeup remover. I am notoriously bad at eyeliner, which is really tragic because i love it so much. Ahead, 22 waterproof eyeliners that will actually stay on your face when the weather warms up. The 35-degree angle of the eyeliner makes it comfortable to hold and apply in one smooth stroke.


Jane Iredale, Mystikol, Powdered Eyeliner, Onyx, 0.06 oz (1.75 g)

$18.00

The first eyeliners i ever really loved were the urban decay 24/7 glide-on eye pencils. There are some reports that the small, plastic insert that prevents too much liquid eyeliner from covering the brush has a tendency to break. I was able to glide the eyeliner over glittery shadows in one swipe. A lot of them crease and smudge easily, a nightmare scenario for anyone trying to master a fierce cat eye. You should remove all of your makeup thoroughly before sleeping each day, and always avoid rubbing, tugging, or scrubbing your face. Sanz sought to develop an all-encompassing make up line for fashion and show-business professionals that contained every kind of product, texture and color needed to achieve any effect a makeup artist could desire. This eyeliner glides on smoothly and stays put! I thought i was done discovering favorite eyeliners until the marc jacobs highliner gel eye crayon eyeliner hit my desk. Most waterproof eyeliners are also longer lasting than other formulations. I’m not a liquid eyeliner kind of person, though i really admire the look. Wet n wild’s megaliner is one of the first eyeliners i ever used.


Lorac, Front of the Line, Pro Liquid Eyeliner, Black, 0.02 fl oz (0.55 ml)

$14.50

This creamy gel eyeliner kit comes with 2 classic colors that can be used for both eyelashes and eyebrows. Do you have to wear eyeliner with mascara? And if you are looking for serious staying power as well as a versatile product, the bobbi brown long-wear gel eyeliner was the best gel eyeliner we tested. After wearing it for a while, several testers reported that the eyeliner migrated or smudged, and yet all who commented on removal said it was a little difficult to get off. If you do not mind spending extra, bobbi brown makes a brush specifically to go with it’s gel liner, the bobbi brown ultra fine eye liner brush ($28). If you do not like the hassle of using a separate brush to apply gel eyeliner then this will make you happy! The stila stay all day waterproof liquid eyeliner allows you to create the style of eyeliner that you desire. Nars eye paint, $25, testers found this stayed on well, but the formula was too dry as they were painting it on, resulting in gaps in coverage or the need for many more strokes than usual.


Lorac, Front of the Line, Pro Liquid Eyeliner, Dark Brown, 0.02 fl oz (0.55 ml)

$14.90

I’m not a liquid eyeliner kind of person, though i really admire the look. However, within a few hours it starts falling out and smudging underneath my eyes making me look like uncle fester. This dermatologically tested eyeliner lasts at least 12 hours and can create either ultra-fine or dramatic lines. However, not all eyeliners are the same. While this eyeliner is nearly perfectly formulated, many customers have had a problem with the bottle itself. Plus, it gives a bit of a slick look when i apply it the bottom inner rims of my eyes. Insanely easy to use, cheap, and lasts forever, both in quantity, but i can literally wear this stuff all day, sleep in it, and wake up and my cat eye still looks good. Unlike some other eyeliner pencils, this one does not skip or leave an uneven color. They suggest using an eyeshadow primer before applying if you have oily or combination skin.


Imju, Dejavu, Lasting-Fine Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner, Glossy Black, 0.01 oz (0.55 ml)

$11.30

Product bled into eye even after a desired amount of drying had occurred and after 2 hours or less, product was black smudge under both eyes! Make up for ever joined forces with pop star charli xcx to create this collection of aqua xl eye pencil waterproof eyeliners. If you do not like the hassle of using a separate brush to apply gel eyeliner then this will make you happy! While it does not apply as buttery and smooth as other liners, it sets down and stays put on my water line without irritating my eyes. I could even see makeup beginners getting great results when using it. Blue eyeliner drawn right under the eyebrow? The eyeliner goes on smooth and i did not have any problems putting it on my eyes the smudge pencil went on my eyes to,they are a great combination. Anything that claims to be supermodel skinny makes me want to immediately hate it out of jealousy, but this liquid eyeliner rocks my world. It is difficult to find an eyeliner that is completely waterproof, but most can withstand at least a little water. The rimmel exaggerate eye definer goes on smooth and produces a deep color. Created by renowned parisian makeup artist dany sanz, who was originally a painter and sc…


Wet n Wild, ProLine Felt Tip Eyeliner, Dark Brown, 0.017 oz (0.5 g)

$3.40

I bought this eyeliner in anger after docolor reformulated and was hot garbage and the epic ink liner i bought to replace it would leak eyeliner like crazy and then subsequently dried out. The best part about this eyeliner has to be the precise tip of the felt tip applicator. Why did it cosmetics create this product: To finally give women a skin-loving anti-aging yet ultra luxe and rich in color eyeliner that is truly waterproof and does not tug on the delicate eye area during application. Use the no tug gel eye liner to define the inner/outer rims of your eyes or use above or below your lash line. In fact, i had to remove it with eye makeup remover wipes at the end of the day to get the last of it off. The ultra-fine tip can give you super precise thin lines, but also lets you build up the product to achieve an intense, thick cat eye. The tip of this eyeliner will give you full control of a defined line. Although it stays on all day, it is quite easy to remove with a makeup remover and does not cause any irritation. The ultimate list of the best eyeliners out in the market. At night, reach for top-tested neutrogena oil-free eye makeup remover to take it all off. You can make mu…


E.L.F, Lock on Liner and Brow Cream, Espresso, 0.19 oz (5.5 g)

$5.00

For maximum color payoff, warm the tip of the eyebrow pencil on the back of your hand before applying. The microfine brush tip is meant to deliver feather-like strokes that look like actual brow hairs. Richly saturated and water resistant, this formula has the precision of a gel and the ease of a pencil. I always come back to elizabeth arden’s beautiful color natural eye brow pencil. With two universal shades to choose from, this all-in-one brow definer from bareminerals makes things easy as it grooms and defines the brows with one swipe. Been mostly using it for over 3 decades and no matter what age you are or how your eyes are aging, lightly melt tip with lighter, softly blow on it to cool it some and poof you have yourself the best soft liner pencil in black there is and it stays on the inside of your eyelids the longest too. The formula contains coconut oil and palm oil which hold the shape of the brows for longer. But with this electric pencil sharpener it just takes me a couple of minutes to sharpen about 50 pencils.


Rimmel London, Scandaleyes Micro Eyeliner, 001 Black, .037 fl oz (1.1 ml)

$3.50

The liner is formulated to glide easily across your skin and apply evenly, which eliminates many of the problems pencil eyeliners tend to have. To gently remove your eyeliner, lightly dab and rinse your eyes, making sure to moisturize after to prevent your skin from drying out. Everyone has their preference for what makes the perfect eyeliner, but any decent liner should be strongly pigmented and transfer-resistant. So when i heard that too faced would be releasing the better than sex liquid eyeliner, i was intrigued to learn more. If you have smaller or hooded eyes, the precision of the applicator makes easy work of hard to reach spots like the inner corners and lash line. So i was excited to try this one because my usual tends to fade midday on my bottom lids, and it often settles into the corners of my eyes. This eyeliner uses liquid, but is not prone to smudging and designed to be worn for up to 12 hours. If they had to pick one eyeliner to use for the rest of their lives, they would pick this one, and i would have to say that i completely agree with them. This creates the illusion that the eyes are closer. Ask for long-lasting eyeliner and we shall deliver! The only complai…


Revlon, Colorstay, Liquid Liner, Black Brown, 0.08 oz (2.5 ml)

$5.50

A lot of the users say that this has officially become their go-to drugstore eyeliner. I just grab the color i want to fit my mood and swipe it on my lid with some eyeshadow on my lower lash line and inner corner. It appeared that the entire eyeliner had peeled off and was stuck to the lash in blotches on the magnets. Thank you for asking about the retractable eyeliner. I’ve been doing my eyeliner the same way for going on five years – a very dark and very thick cat eye. Honestly, when i first got my hands on the uz eye opening liner, i was weary about whether it would abide by them. Insanely easy to use, cheap, and lasts forever, both in quantity, but i can literally wear this stuff all day, sleep in it, and wake up and my cat eye still looks good. Who is it for: Anyone who wants rich luxe eyeliner color and application without tugging on the delicate eyelids. If your almond eyes are small, go with a thinner line for the inner corners and make it gradually thicker as you get to the outer corners. The last thing you want is a dull, pale eyeliner. Last but not least, the perfect liner should be able to last most of the day while being easy enough to wash away with makeup remover …


L’Oreal, Pencil Perfect, Self-Advancing Eyeliner, 130 Espresso, .01 oz (280 mg)

$6.70

Some people might also use it on the bottom eyelid, though you will be hard pressed to find a style that uses eyeliner on only the bottom lid. This eyeliner has been an all time favorite of mine for a while now due to the fact that it is highly pigmented, perfect for creating a dramatic look and never smudges off. If you enjoy trying new eyeliner styles or regularly wear complex makeup, you might want to give this eyeliner a try. My absolute all time favorite eyeliner is chanel le crayon kohl in noir because it’s richly pigmented and glides on nicely. The formula is super smooth, does not pull on your eye, and does not bleed so it’s easy to get a nice wing. Regardless of the look we choose, we need the best eyeliners, from the perfect smudgy kohl to a precise, smudge-proof liquid liner, to get the job done. Ahead, 22 waterproof eyeliners that will actually stay on your face when the weather warms up. I just grab the color i want to fit my mood and swipe it on my lid with some eyeshadow on my lower lash line and inner corner. If you find yourself scrubbing your face raw to remove stubborn makeup, we recommend either switching to a different eyeliner, or consider using a stronger …


Revlon, PhotoReady, Eye Art, 060 Peach Prism, 0.2 fl oz (6 ml)

$6.50

I love how a cat eye looks on me and only use liquid liner to help me create a precise, fine line with a flicked out wing. It might help to pull your skin tight when using eyeliner. The docolor waterproof eyeliner pen is designed to deliver precise, sharp lines and intense color. For most people who regularly wear make-up, eyeliner is necessary to complete the look. Of course, you should also make sure the color the eyeliner produces is vibrant and rich. When most people wear eyeliner, they wear it on at least their top eyelid. Or if you prefer the more low-key look of an off-duty model, we recommend reaching for the best neutral cream winner, the supergoop shimmershade eyeshadow, for a subtle wash of color on your lids. A good stick of eyeliner should be able to do multiple jobs. I have tried lots of cheaper brands in hopes of finding a good one, but sadly they mostly get donated to my young daughter’s play makeup kit. With a wide range of beautiful shades to pick from such as mint, spicy burgundy and hot pink, kiko cosmetics lasting precision automatic eyeliner and kohl gives a seamless application with the ease of a twist-up pencil and a precise blending sponge on the other e…


L’Oreal, Lineur Intense Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner, Black Mica 610, .05 fl oz (1.5 ml)

$6.70

That being said, it is fairly easy to take it off with some makeup remover. Urban decay 24/7 glide-on eye pencil comes in a billion easy-to-blend shades for every style of makeup. There are some reports that the small, plastic insert that prevents too much liquid eyeliner from covering the brush has a tendency to break. With one video, nine eyeliner hacks, and a pep talk from lindsay, i pulled off a fairly respectable cat eye on the first try. I did not have to rub at my eyes and irritate them to remove the eyeliner. Most surprisingly, the better than sex liquid eyeliner truly was one of the easiest i have ever used. The liner is formulated to glide easily across your skin and apply evenly, which eliminates many of the problems pencil eyeliners tend to have.


Wet n Wild, MegaLiner Metallic Liquid Eyeliner, Metallic Brown, 0.12 fl oz (3.5 ml)

$3.00

I have tried many of the best liquid eyeliners over the years, and this is right up there on the list. What is even better is that i can do a cat eye in the morning before work, go out the same night, return home and the lines are still perfectly in place – no smudging. The best part about this eyeliner has to be the precise tip of the felt tip applicator. The shape of your eye can influence the thickness and quality of the line you apply, such as using a long, thin line to lengthen a round eye. Even a day at the pool cannot get in the way of this liquid eyeliner. The uz eye opening liner is now a staple in my makeup bag because with it’s paint brush applicator i can create a bright colorful look with just a flick of the wrist. Using eye primer beforehand can also keep your handiwork intact. If you struggle with getting your cat eye to stay in place, it might be time to switch to a waterproof version.


Julep, When Pencil Met Gel, Long-Lasting Eyeliner, Blackest Black, 0.042 oz (1.20 g)

$9.10

A lot of them crease and smudge easily, a nightmare scenario for anyone trying to master a fierce cat eye. The best part about this eyeliner has to be the precise tip of the felt tip applicator. That being said, it is fairly easy to take it off with some makeup remover. The last thing anyone needs after bumping into an ex, boss, or in-laws is to realize that your flawless morning eyeliner has transformed into raccoon eyes. Wet n wild’s megaliner is one of the first eyeliners i ever used. I would recommend this product to anyone, whether you are a professional makeup artist or are a beginner wanting to try out a wing liner. Using eye primer beforehand can also keep your handiwork intact. With this eyeliner, you get complete control of your look. My cat eyes have been turning out so clean and beautiful. Writer alison freer loves her vamp stamp, an eyeliner stamp designed by a makeup artist who lost feeling in her hands after being diagnosed with a benign spinal-cord tumor.


L’Oreal, Telescopic Control Tip Liquid Eyeliner, 820 Charcoal, .08 fl oz (2.45 ml)

$7.40

If you want shade options, the marc jacobs beauty highliner gel eye crayon eyeliner can give it to you with a whopping 33 shades, ranging from shimmer to matte to satin to glitter finishes. You gently dip the stamp into the little pot of eyeliner ink, then press firmly onto the ends of your eyes. Cat eyes are next to impossible to do on me (Even pro artists struggle with it), so i do not wear black eyeliner all that often anymore. Check out the latest eyeliner picks from the good housekeeping institute beauty lab and our makeup experts. We have compiled their favorite gel, liquid, pencil, pen and waterproof eyeliners that cost less than $10, these cheap eyeliners do not smudge or disappear, but they also are easily removed with eye makeup remover. Microliner is wonderful for lining the waterline if you have small eyes or creating a very small and defined line along the upper or lower lashes. I always look to glossier when it comes time to stock my everyday makeup bag.


E.L.F, Kohl Eyeliner, Black, 0.09 oz (2.7 g)

$4.20

Best eyeliners are one among the higher store liquid eyeliners out there. Then i took my make up off and the flyliner had stained my eyes, with what looked like a faint tattoo of eyeliner wings for about two days even with me scrubbing it off and showering so i will not be using it again which is a shame because i have and love all other fenty beauty products. Eyeliners have been used for centuries to create dramatic shapes and designs around the eye. You could even draw on flicks with the best liquid eyeliner winner, the too faced better than sex liner. The velvety formulation feels gentle on delicate skin, making it an ideal eyeliner for sensitive eyes. No matter what look you have in mind, you can create it with one of these eyeliners. But should you want to channel your inner mother makeup and play, this soft formula allows for a solid amount of freestyling on your end before it sets. What it is: An ultimate life-proof, dual-ended liquid and pencil eyeliner that is long-lasting, waterproof, smudge-proof, and fade-proof. This australian owned company keeps it simple and carefully selects their ingredients to create gentle, highly effective natural makeup.


E.L.F, Intense Ink Eyeliner. Blackest Black, 0.088 oz (2.5 g)

$5.00

A quick tutorial and first impression video on how to apply eyeliner for beginners- using a stencil! Sharp eye and lip pencils apply more easily and create a more precise line for a professional look. If you have got hooded, or eye shapes, maybe, the manner your eye creases will hide or distort your war paint. In selecting eyeliner styles, be sure to consider your eye color, skin complexion, makeup theme and most importantly your age. Save money on your beauty supplies today. I purchased the light and the medium shade as some days i use more bronzer or will have used a faux tan product and this way i have both shades to match a radiant eye liner that also doubles as an eye shadow. If you want your eyeballs to look like themselves, only better, try this eyeliner that only comes in one color, and one color, only: Waterline flesh color. Waterproof makeup goes on swimmingly while not skipping, smudging, or pulling best black liner to form the right cat eye.


Covergirl, Perfect Point Plus, Eye Pencil, 205 Charcoal, .008 oz (0.23 g)

$5.30

Everyone has their preference for what makes the perfect eyeliner, but any decent liner should be strongly pigmented and transfer-resistant. Nothing looks worse than smudged eyeliner. This creates the illusion of narrower and longer eyes. Em cosmetics was founded by og beauty influencer michelle phan, and the girl knows makeup. It is easy to apply and stays on better than most other eyeliners i have used. This highly concentrated eyeliner holds pigments in a clear gel base that is safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. The main purpose of eyeliner is to provide a defined line of color. With this product, simply line up the stamp from the corner of your eye to the end of your eyebrow to create the same wing on each side.


Wet n Wild, MegaLiner Liquid Eyeliner, Voltage Blue, 0.12 fl oz (3.5 ml)

$3.00

It did smudge under my eyes after a while, which forced me to clean them up a bit toward the end of the day. Quick eyeliner application hack: Rest your elbow on a tabletop as you work. This creates the illusion that the eyes are closer. Maybe i will use the white liner with a matte pink eye shadow on my lower lash line and matte orange eye shadow in my inner corner, or i will use the bright baby blue liner with a pastel pink on the waterline and a shimmery purple eyeshadow in the inner corner. You can use them to create defined winged liner, do a messy smokey eye, or to tightline around the inner part of your eyelid for additional drama. It’s time to say goodbye to smudged raccoon eyes and having to reapply at noon, and hello to these eyeliners that are colorful, cheap and long lasting. Once the effects of the cream kick in, the whole process should theoretically be pretty painless, meyer said. With this product, simply line up the stamp from the corner of your eye to the end of your eyebrow to create the same wing on each side.


L’Oreal, Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner, 960 Cobalt Blue, 0.042 fl oz (1.2 g)

$6.70

We reviewed dozens of eyeliners to help you choose the best of the best. I could even see makeup beginners getting great results when using it. The liner truly stays where you put, no matter how hungry your eyelids are. Normally any liquid or gel liner i wear transfers onto the creases of my eyes by midday or evening – i have combo skin and lids that disappear when i open my eyes – a bad environment for any liner. Insanely easy to use, cheap, and lasts forever, both in quantity, but i can literally wear this stuff all day, sleep in it, and wake up and my cat eye still looks good. It stays on through the day on most part of my eye, although outside corners run early in the day. Users rave that this is the perfect eyeliner for both pros and amateurs. Also, you can adopt a longer wing at the corners of the eyes to help them open up. This eyeliner began to dry within less than two weeks. I just grab the color i want to fit my mood and swipe it on my lid with some eyeshadow on my lower lash line and inner corner.


E.L.F, Lock On, Liner And Brow Cream, Medium Brown, 0.19 oz (5.5 g)

$5.00

Do you use eyebrow pencils to make your brows look fuller? It looks like the cool place you’d want your makeup to come out of. Fill any bald spots with brow powder to get an even shape. I could tell the color on the shu uemura seal brown pencil was perfect as soon as i saw it. Luckily, the urban decay brow box contains everything you could possibly need for perfect brows in one chic, compact kit that can be tossed in your purse. A great multipurpose product which contains a brow pencil at one end and a brow gel at another, this pencil from smashbox will give you smashing brows in just a few seconds. Formula: The ultra-fine point pencil means you can easily draw on individual hairs to give the appearance of a thicker, fuller arch. It’s a must-have for those with thick brows, since it helps tame and lock hairs into place for a simple, groomed look. You can vary the sharpness of your points by adjusting the centre lever, and it is big enough to fit the nyx jumbo pencils.


Maybelline, TattooStudio, Gel Eyeliner Pencil, 900 Deep Onyx, 0.04 oz (12 g)

$5.40

It is infused with eyelash growth serum and castor oil to help your eyes pop even after you take it off. If you decide to apply eyeliner to your bottom lid, pull your skin tight and gently apply the eyeliner over your lashes. While this eyeliner is less expensive than much of the competition, it is still great quality. Figuring out what eye makeup to wear is one of our biggest daily morning decisions (Along with deciding whether it’s a dark roast or an espresso day). However, not all eyeliners are the same. Aside from bobbi brown, the other eyeliners provided more mixed experiences, but clinique brush-on cream liner ($17) Seemed to serve panelists second-best. This eyeliner takes a very long time to dry out so choosing the bigger option should not cause you to waste any. Absolutely love this eyeliner, i never feel like my make up is quite complete until i have used it. It had the smoothest application of the four pencil eyeliners we tested: Our tester praised how effortlessly it glided onto her lid and waterline. This eyeliner began to dry within less than two weeks. If reviews reported that the pigmentation in an eyeliner was not dark or faded easily, we discarded it from consi…


L’Oreal, Infallible Mechanical Eyeliner, 511 Black, 0.008 oz (240 mg)

$6.70

After uncapping the eyeliner, i could see that the tip of the pen was covered in promising shiny ink. Because of it’s versatility, you can drill down the tip of this eyeliner to a blunt edge for a polished point or dull it on your hand for a softer smear. Without eyeliner, a look can easily look incomplete and sloppy. It also provides 2 small eye makeup brushes, one regular liner brush and one angle liner brush that help you easily create different eyeliner styles. Once applied, this eyeliner performs fairly well. Eyeliners are basically the mvp of eye makeup, and one wrong move can result in a slew of black marks ruining the flawless mug you spent nearly two hours creating. This highly concentrated eyeliner holds pigments in a clear gel base that is safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. To apply eyeliner, you should begin at the inner corner at work across.


E.L.F, Long-Lasting Lustrous Eyeshadow, Toast, 0.11 oz (3.0 g)

$4.20

Use this to create a soft shimmering effect from the inner corner of the eyelid and smoke out underneath your bottom lashes. The shiny finish of the eyeliner also paired perfectly with the iridescent glow of my eye shadow, which i appreciated. Loaded with lash-plumping peptides and conditioners, marc jacobs beauty velvet primer amplifies the effect of your mascara. Back in ancient times (Think cleopatra) people would grind up stibnite or charcoal to use as eyeshadow and eyeliner for the eyes to give them a more dramatic look. Point the ergonomically designed felt tip toward the inner corner of the eye. Black eyeliner is classic, but if you really want to make your eyes pop, use a color that really complements your eyes. Fuel your self expression with an award-winning lineup of waterproof liners, eye makeup, prismatic highlighters, vegan makeup brushes, and the iconic liquid lipsticks that started the craze. In addition, the eye shadow primer that comes with one of the palates (I cannot remember which one) is so stinkin awesome, i hope they start selling it separately. Yellow eyeliner used to create a star on the side of rico’s face? Our professional makeup brushes provide you wi…


Covergirl, Perfect Point Plus, Eye Pencil, 210 Espresso, .008 oz (0.23 g)

$5.30

To remove eyeliner using eye makeup remover, simply soak a cotton ball or pad in the solution, press gently against your eye for a few moments, and wipe gently until all traces of your eye makeup have been removed. I love how soft this eyeliner feels – it glides right on, and is the perfect consistency for smudging, ideal if you are going for a smoky eye look. For a naturally defined look, gently pull up the eyelid and line the upper rim as if you were filling in between the eyelashes. These products are specially formulated to dissolve eye makeup so that it wipes off without a lot of rubbing, which could irritate the delicate skin around your eyes. Users say that they literally cannot live without this eyeliner. It’s a go-to item in everyone’s makeup bag, and there is no shortage of options out there (Take a quick trip to the drugstore beauty aisle and you will see what we mean) but finding the best formulas is no easy feat. To gently remove your eyeliner, lightly dab and rinse your eyes, making sure to moisturize after to prevent your skin from drying out. I could even see makeup beginners getting great results when using it. A lot of them crease and smudge easily, a nightmare…


Revlon, Colorstay, Eyeliner, 202 Black Brown, 0.01 oz (0.28 g)

$5.70

For the novice: Apply to the upper lash line holding the applicator with one hand and gently stretching the eye lid with the other. Testers gave it top scores for helping them create their perfect look and applying smoothly onto eyelids without tugging or skipping. If you want shade options, the marc jacobs beauty highliner gel eye crayon eyeliner can give it to you with a whopping 33 shades, ranging from shimmer to matte to satin to glitter finishes. If you find yourself scrubbing your face raw to remove stubborn makeup, we recommend either switching to a different eyeliner, or consider using a stronger makeup remover. Described as a gel pot eyeliner in a crayon, the highliner contains vitamin e and rosehip seed oil, both of which contribute to the glide-on application. It has a felt tip applicator and a pot, which makes it easy to apply and prevents it from running out of product or drying up like many pen style felt-tip eyeliners do. Pencil is the easiest of the three eyeliner formats to use and gives you good control over the quality of line, especially if you keep it well-sharpened. What is it: No-tug waterproof gel eye liners glide on saturated rich color without tugging o…


Revlon, PhotoReady, Eye Art, 100 Topaz Twinkle, 0.2 fl oz (6 ml)

$6.50

The easiest way to decipher through it all is to think about the makeup look you want to create, and then choose the type of liner that will give you the result. All eyeshadows and eyeliners in this kit were ocular tested to ensure they would not irritate eyes or interfere with contacts. So i was excited to try this one because my usual tends to fade midday on my bottom lids, and it often settles into the corners of my eyes. Despite the plastic-coated appearance of the eyeliner, it can be sharpened with a cosmetic sharpener. Of course, it is always a good idea to have multiple shades of eyeliner available so you can more carefully match it to your style and eyeshadow choice. After reviewing dozens of products, the maybelline eyestudio master precise all day liquid eyeliner makeup stood out to us as the best. Designed to be long-lasting and precise, stila stay all day waterproof liquid eye liner is a wonderful option for those who prefer liquid eyeliner. This essential makeup brush set includes eye shadow brushes, eye liner, eye pencil and blending brush. We do not recommend applying eyeliner on your waterline because it often causes the eyeliner to migrate into your eye, which c…


Physicians Formula, Eye Booster, Ultra Fine Liquid Eyeliner with Lash Conditioning Serum, Deep Brown, 0.016 fl oz (0.5 ml)

$7.20

The other key feature of this eyeliner is in it’s staying power. The velvety formulation feels gentle on delicate skin, making it an ideal eyeliner for sensitive eyes. -Soak up cotton pads in makeup remover and apply on the eyes massaging gently to break up the formula. I just have really big eyes (And thus really big eyelids), so i find drawing a good cat eye impossibly hard. As the star of your makeup bag, eyeliners work to accentuate the eyes, darken the space between sparse lashes and adds drama. No matter how you like to apply your eyeliner (Subtle or dramatic), you want to know it’s going to last all day. If you do not want to be bothered with a separate sharpener for your eyeliner pencils, you will appreciate the convenience of sephora’s retractable waterproof eyeliner pencil. This is especially true of the eye area we we refer to as the waterline; that thin, wet strip of flesh where the edge of your eyelid hangs out with your eyeball. The formulation is infused with antioxidants and works for even the most sensitive eyes. Happy customers praise the vibrant colors, smudge-free performance, and ease of gliding the pencil around the eyes. This is one of the most popular gel…


L’Oreal, Lineur Intense, Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner, Carbon Black 690, .05 fl oz (1.5 ml)

$6.70

If you want a dark base for eyeshadow, then this will work perfectly. Use on the upper lid and inner waterline and if you want a smoky eye. The shape of your eye can influence the thickness and quality of the line you apply, such as using a long, thin line to lengthen a round eye. I would recommend this product to anyone, whether you are a professional makeup artist or are a beginner wanting to try out a wing liner. So we decided to put a ton of long-lasting eyeliners to the test. Without eyeliner, a look can easily look incomplete and sloppy. A good stick of eyeliner should be able to do multiple jobs. Meyer said many of her clients come back after about a year to get touch-ups. For a glossy look with intense shine, this eyeliner glides on smoothly for precise lines and designs. If you struggle with getting your cat eye to stay in place, it might be time to switch to a waterproof version. I have used maybelline expertwear in black for years for eyebrows and sometimes as eyeliner, but hard to find in stores now. You should remove all of your makeup thoroughly before sleeping each day, and always avoid rubbing, tugging, or scrubbing your face.


Physicians Formula, Eye Booster, Ultra Fine Liquid Eyeliner with Lash Conditioning Serum, Ultra Black, 0.016 fl oz (0.5 ml)

$7.20

A zero-transfer eyeliner designed to give the most artful application, christian louboutin’s velvet eye kohl definer pencil glides on as beautifully as it’s packaging. Mac cosmetics powersurge kohl eyeliner certainly lives up to it’s name, as it gives a generous surge of color in just one application, making it the perfect liner for those who have a time limit on their makeup in the morning or want a few, simple key steps for eyes. The pink shade featured here is perfect for illuminating and creating brightness around the eye, and the smudging tip on the opposite end allows you to blend in seconds without the need for any extra brushes. The skinny paintbrush tip of too faced better than sex easy glide waterproof liquid eyeliner gives us the tightest of lines and the smoothest of strokes. Color gives depth to lashes and enhances the eyes for a more radiant look. Each end of the wand is a stamp: One for your left eye and one for your right. Instead, you can draw a very thin line above your lashes, tapering the eyeliner outwards from the last third of your lashes to create a subtle flick. Recently, at a family engagement party, my own father asked if i had gone in for eyelash exten…


Angfa, Scalp-D Beaute, Pure Free Eyeliner, Dark Brown, 0.02 fl oz (0.57 ml)

$16.50

This eyeliner goes the extra mile in helping you look good. One of my favorite looks to do with this liner is honestly a cat eye because it’s foolproof and the perfect solution for when i am running late and do not have time for a full eyeshadow look. Our slim eye pencil has a shimmer to it! Lol if you have a shaky hand and need something that compensates for it, you really should purchase the harder eyeliner pencils that need to be sharpened with a standard pencil sharpener. Without eyeliner, a look can easily look incomplete and sloppy. A pro artist favorite, aqua xl eye pencil waterproof liner’s superior, long-lasting formula will not smudge, crease, or fade until you remove it. This pencil also comes with a built-in smudger to diversify your eyeliner look.


Covergirl, Perfect Blend, Eye Pencil, 100 Basic Black, .03 oz (.85 g)

$5.30

My all time favorite liquid eyeliner, i have used kat von d, stila, and countless other brands but i always come back to this. For most people, this eyeliner should last the majority of the workday. If you regularly use eyeliner, the maybelline eyestudio master precise all-day liquid eyeliner makeup is the one to get. If you want a dark base for eyeshadow, then this will work perfectly. After just one swipe, i was officially a uz eye opening liner convert, though. Should i wear eyeliner on the top or bottom? Most eyeliner styles require a steady hand and precise lines. The shiny finish of the eyeliner also paired perfectly with the iridescent glow of my eye shadow, which i appreciated. Our goal: Find which eyeliners offer the smoothest, most controlled application, budge-proof wear, and painless removal. The formula is super smooth, does not pull on your eye, and does not bleed so it’s easy to get a nice wing. So i did not realize when i volunteered to test-drive an eyeliner that it was a liquid eyeliner, but when this landed on my desk, i knew i did not have a choice.


L.A. Girl, Fineline Liquid Eyeliner, Black, 0.037 fl oz (1.1 ml)

$4.50

I tend to have oily skin, so some eyeliners will pretty much just melt off shortly after application. The following 5 are the most popular gel eyeliners in the world. For a glossy look with intense shine, this eyeliner glides on smoothly for precise lines and designs. When you put eyeliner on, you expect it to last. When most people wear eyeliner, they wear it on at least their top eyelid. We recommend purchasing an eyeliner that is easy to use with a thin yet durable tip. This eyeliner goes the extra mile in helping you look good. I thought i was done discovering favorite eyeliners until the marc jacobs highliner gel eye crayon eyeliner hit my desk. But to my surprise i put the left cat eye on first and it was perfect aside from needing to connect it to my current liner. To gently remove your eyeliner, lightly dab and rinse your eyes, making sure to moisturize after to prevent your skin from drying out.


Maybelline, Line Stiletto, Ultimate Precision Liquid Eyeliner, 501 Blackest Black, 0.05 fl oz (1.5 ml)

$5.40

We sourced the most eyeliner-savvy members of our editorial team to take home a few eyeliners each for a week of testing. They also make glimmersticks for eyeliner and lipliner. Sharpening this eyeliner is a bit tricky, but with a good quality sharpener, it should be just fine! For most people who regularly wear make-up, eyeliner is necessary to complete the look. Maybe i will use the white liner with a matte pink eye shadow on my lower lash line and matte orange eye shadow in my inner corner, or i will use the bright baby blue liner with a pastel pink on the waterline and a shimmery purple eyeshadow in the inner corner. You can create a huge variety of looks from the classic cat-eye to a very natural doe eye. Choosing an eyeliner that is designed not to smudge is incredibly important.


Imju, Dejavu, Lasting-Fine Retractable Eyeliner Pencil, Deep Black, 0.005 oz (0.15 g)

$11.30

A stamp for the right eye and left eye on the end of liquid eyeliner pencil with a liner on the other side of each pencil. As a liquid eyeliner and general beauty junkie, i can be very critical of new products but love trying them out. For a glossy look with intense shine, this eyeliner glides on smoothly for precise lines and designs. So, can we get a great eyeliner without breaking the bank? It is easy to apply and can be used as both eyeliner and eyeshadow. What is even better is that i can do a cat eye in the morning before work, go out the same night, return home and the lines are still perfectly in place – no smudging. So i was excited to try this one because my usual tends to fade midday on my bottom lids, and it often settles into the corners of my eyes. I always enjoy this eyeliner, it stays on really good never runs and has a nice and tip brush. For a clearly defined or sultry look, add a line above the lash line as well as the lower rim and set with eye shadow. I have always used liquid eye liner and my lines would come out kinda crooked, sometimes the product would get dry really quickly and disappear or even worse it would melt and end up all over my face.


L’Oreal, Infallible Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner, Black 400, 0.034 fl oz (1 ml)

$6.70

This eyeliner is extremely long-lasting, with up to 16 hours of duration. You can keep the line super precise, or smudge it out before it dries for a smokey eye look. The hourglass 1,5 mm mechanical gel eye liner has an extremely fine tip, allowing for maximum precision. Why did it cosmetics create this product: To finally give women a skin-loving anti-aging yet ultra luxe and rich in color eyeliner that is truly waterproof and does not tug on the delicate eye area during application. The ingredients included in this winged eyeliner stamp are candelilla wax, and carnauba wax which ensure the liquid dries quickly and holds on strong. I am notoriously bad at eyeliner, which is really tragic because i love it so much. While this eyeliner is nearly perfectly formulated, many customers have had a problem with the bottle itself. To create a flattering eye shape, extend the line slightly at the outer corner. To protect your sensitive eyes, regularly switch out your eyeliner. Insanely easy to use, cheap, and lasts forever, both in quantity, but i can literally wear this stuff all day, sleep in it, and wake up and my cat eye still looks good.


E.L.F, Lock On, Liner And Brow Cream, Light Brown, 0.19 oz (5.5 g)

$5.00

Another great tip to make your brows look professionally done is to blend them using two colors. Choose from the wide range of eyebrow pencils, eyebrow kits and eyebrow gels to create a natural but defined-looking brow. This brow gel is not tinted but rather clear, working to comb existing brows into the shape of your choice. But with this electric pencil sharpener it just takes me a couple of minutes to sharpen about 50 pencils. As part of the eye makeup range currently available in india, there is a gel pencil eyeliner, a liquid felt-tip eyeliner, dual ended fiber mascara and two shades of brow pencil. Use an eyebrow pencil to create your perfect arch and elongate the the look of your brow, while you brush up your eyebrows with an eyebrow gel to set it in place. The main thing about this product is that it’s simply a basic pencil. With 10 diverse shades to offer, this pencil from one of the most popular brow brands, anastasia beverly hills, is a bestseller for it’s natural finish. I have used it on various eye liners and brow pencils. If you have thin or light brows, eyebrow pencils can make them look thicker and fuller in an instant. I found the soft powder easy to use, but i…


Sam Marcel, Luxurious Liner, Black, 0.018 fl oz (0.55 ml)

$16.20

So i was excited to try this one because my usual tends to fade midday on my bottom lids, and it often settles into the corners of my eyes. Use on the upper lid and inner waterline and if you want a smoky eye. Like most beauty products, in my opinion, this eyeliner is not perfect. Anything that claims to be supermodel skinny makes me want to immediately hate it out of jealousy, but this liquid eyeliner rocks my world. But, after doing a few test swipes on my hand, it easily wiped off reassuring me that i would not have to live with my eyes lined in a vibrant navy hue for the rest of my days. Although it stays on all day, it is quite easy to remove with a makeup remover and does not cause any irritation. I am notoriously bad at eyeliner, which is really tragic because i love it so much. First is the tightline, which involves adding the pigment between the layers of your eyelashes to darken your lash line, leaving you with a subtle lash enhancement, tai said. If this describes you, there is absolutely no reason to force yourself to wear eyeliner. I was skeptical that this eyeliner would be as waterproof as it claims and i was totally shocked!


Revlon, Colorstay, Skinny Liquid Liner, Black Out 301, 0.08 oz (2.5 ml)

$5.50

I have deep-set eyes that eat eyeliner for breakfast. Everyone we talked to said a tightline application should generally heal within three to seven days, but a thicker eyeliner application may take seven to 10 days. Both eye color and the shape of your eyes should impact your choice of eyeliner. Foodpharmacy Blog considers this the absolute best pencil eyeliner on the market, thanks to easy application and long-lasting wear. You’ll never need to dig around in the bottom of your makeup bag to sharpen this pencil. The best part about this eyeliner has to be the precise tip of the felt tip applicator. I just grab the color i want to fit my mood and swipe it on my lid with some eyeshadow on my lower lash line and inner corner.


Physicians Formula, Shimmer Strips, Custom Eye Enhancing Shadow & Liner, Nude, 0.26 oz (7.5 g)

$7.40

It is specifically designed for the mature face, using active ingredients with anti-ageing properties, including precious minerals (Amethyst and tourmaline) to remove creases and firm the contours of the eyes. The home of the makeup breakup – the original and the best makeup destroying series on youtube. His on equally well on both upper and lower eyelids and does not smear, i finally found a product that ends my search. Shop black, brown, and colored eyeliner from a variety of top brands, including covergirl, revlon, rimmel, milani, maybelline, and nyx. Com, sales tax, service fees, delivery charges, beauty salon, restaurant purchases, corporate gifts, alterations, fur storage, repairs, and gift card purchases. Sanz sought to develop an all-encompassing make up line for fashion and show-business professionals that contained every kind of product, texture and color needed to achieve any effect a makeup artist could desire. Valid on catalog and saks fifth avenue store purchases on 01/23/20 and 01/24/20, excludes some designer collections, leased collections, beauty salons, saks fifth avenue off 5th stores, saksoff5th. Gel eyeliner has a thicker, waxier formula than other types, s…


J.Cat Beauty, Roll It Up, Auto Eye Liner, RAE107 Brown, 0.01 oz (0.3 g)

$2.00

This creates the illusion that the eyes are closer. The shiny finish of the eyeliner also paired perfectly with the iridescent glow of my eye shadow, which i appreciated. Figuring out what eye makeup to wear is one of our biggest daily morning decisions (Along with deciding whether it’s a dark roast or an espresso day). The shape of your eye can influence the thickness and quality of the line you apply, such as using a long, thin line to lengthen a round eye. I just have really big eyes (And thus really big eyelids), so i find drawing a good cat eye impossibly hard. For a glossy look with intense shine, this eyeliner glides on smoothly for precise lines and designs. With that said, in all other areas, this liquid eyeliner is a wonderful choice. When the temperatures rise, the perfect cat eye can quickly turn into a weird smudge on your lids that no one wants to point out for fear of embarrassing you. You gently dip the stamp into the little pot of eyeliner ink, then press firmly onto the ends of your eyes.


L’Oreal, Infallible Mechanical Eyeliner, 591 Carbon Black, 0.008 oz (240 mg)

$6.70

A lot of the users say that this has officially become their go-to drugstore eyeliner. I have somewhat dry skin, and this rimmel eyeliner goes on easily, although with a somewhat uneven line. With this product, simply line up the stamp from the corner of your eye to the end of your eyebrow to create the same wing on each side. Described by glossier as technogel eye pencil, colorslide is a budge-proof eyeliner that goes on smoothly, though it is a bit tackier in texture than marc jacobs and urban decay’s offerings. Everyone has their preference for what makes the perfect eyeliner, but any decent liner should be strongly pigmented and transfer-resistant. Also, my eyes tend to water occasionally and i usually end up wiping some of it off when drying my eyes. It features a small, accurate tip that makes applying all styles of eyeliner very easily. I have been using this charcoal eyeliner for over 10 years.


E.L.F, Lock On, Liner And Brow Cream, Medium Brown, 0.19 oz (5.5 g)

$5.00

Blend till you see a raised eyebrow effect. I have 2 kids and they are at an age where they do a lot of colouring at school and at least once a week i have to sharpen their pencils which used to take a lot of time. Now my easily-broken eyeliners sharpen with no problem at all. When it comes to must-have products, glossier’s boy brow has earned cult status in the makeup bags of editors, influencers, and celebs across the globe. Keep in mind that more than one kind of brow product might apply to you. The colorful packaging makes it easy to identify the pencil in your makeup bag easily. In order to use all of the site functionality on the the bay website, you must have javascript enabled on your browser. The price is very high but the brand is known for it’s quality brow products. The brow fillers that can be mistaken for your favorite felt-tipped liquid liner are prime choices for covering scar tissue or bald spots, madron says. The consistency of the pencil is not very creamy so it takes one-two swipes to build the color but it has a good pigmentation. Try different formulas like pencils, gels and wax before settling on the one which suits your brows by making them look fuller an…


Rimmel London, Scandaleyes, 24HR Wear, Waterproof Kohl Kajal Liner, 001 Black, .04 oz (1.3 g)

$3.00

This is the good old one you have used for years so if you are unhappy with the eyeliner pencils you are finding in the stores now, you will be happy to be back with this one. The best part about this eyeliner has to be the precise tip of the felt tip applicator. Without eyeliner, your eyeshadow can develop an obvious gap near your lashes, and your mascara will not look as dark as it could. You can make multiple looks with only one stick of eyeliner, which can not be said for many other types of makeup. It appeared that the entire eyeliner had peeled off and was stuck to the lash in blotches on the magnets. If you decide to apply eyeliner to your bottom lid, pull your skin tight and gently apply the eyeliner over your lashes. Marc jacobs highliner gel eye crayon eyeliner is the creamiest, most pigmented and blendable pencil eyeliner you will ever use, and it’s available in a ton of colors and finishes. With one video, nine eyeliner hacks, and a pep talk from lindsay, i pulled off a fairly respectable cat eye on the first try. It is infused with eyelash growth serum and castor oil to help your eyes pop even after you take it off. The other side has a very fine tip for defining th…


Rimmel London, Scandaleyes Gel Eyeliner, 001 Black, 0.085 fl oz (2.4 g)

$3.50

For a stronger eyeliner line, it could take two and a half to three hours, she said, noting that she gets her clients involved in the design to make sure the final product will be exactly what they want. Blue eyeliner drawn right under the eyebrow? If they had to pick one eyeliner to use for the rest of their lives, they would pick this one, and i would have to say that i completely agree with them. If you do not like the hassle of using a separate brush to apply gel eyeliner then this will make you happy! Maybe i will use the white liner with a matte pink eye shadow on my lower lash line and matte orange eye shadow in my inner corner, or i will use the bright baby blue liner with a pastel pink on the waterline and a shimmery purple eyeshadow in the inner corner. Check out the latest eyeliner picks from the good housekeeping institute beauty lab and our makeup experts. After trying this for the first time, i now understand why so many people love this eyeliner. The stila stay all day waterproof liquid eyeliner allows you to create the style of eyeliner that you desire.


L.A. Girl, Perfect Precision Eyeliner, Dark Brown, 0.05 oz (1.49 g)

$2.50

It stays on through the day on most part of my eye, although outside corners run early in the day. The eyeliner goes on smooth and i did not have any problems putting it on my eyes the smudge pencil went on my eyes to,they are a great combination. Make up for ever joined forces with pop star charli xcx to create this collection of aqua xl eye pencil waterproof eyeliners. This creates the illusion that the eyes are closer. One of my favorite looks to do with this liner is honestly a cat eye because it’s foolproof and the perfect solution for when i am running late and do not have time for a full eyeshadow look. To help you get the most out of your pencil, this eyeliner comes with a built-in sharpener that actually works. I have deep-set eyes that eat eyeliner for breakfast. The liner is formulated to glide easily across your skin and apply evenly, which eliminates many of the problems pencil eyeliners tend to have. A lot of them crease and smudge easily, a nightmare scenario for anyone trying to master a fierce cat eye. Also, avon glimmerstick (For eyebrows) is very good, but the dark brown is more like auburn. I love how soft this eyeliner feels – it glides right on, and is the …


E.L.F, Long-Lasting Lustrous Eyeshadow, Toast, 0.11 oz (3.0 g)

$4.20

Quick eyeliner application hack: Rest your elbow on a tabletop as you work. Yellow eyeliner used to create a star on the side of rico’s face? Tom ford’s eye kohl intense pencils are ideal for everyday use, and there is a really interesting trick to using the white toned kohl pencil that you might have not realized: When you apply white or nude color to the waterline, it helps the eyes appear larger and brighter, counteracting any redness or bloodshot effect you might have. If your lids tend to look a little reddish or veiny, add a quick application of concealer to even out your complexion and prep for eyeshadow. Like an olympic winner skater in an ice rink, it literally glides across your eyes in the most elegant way. Danusia wnek, good housekeeping institute chemist, health, beauty and environmental sciences lab danusia wnek is a chemist in the health, beauty and environmental sciences lab at the good housekeeping institute, where she evaluates haircare, skincare, cosmetics and beauty and health tools. The smooth texture of the pencil glides on easily, making it the perfect product to blend with your finger or brush should you need to smudge it up a bit, and you will not need t…


Wet n Wild, Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil, You’re Always White!, 0.04 oz (1.4 g)

$1.50

A long-wearing, waterproof eye pencil that pairs ultra-creamy glide with instant color intensity. Gel, too, requires practice to learn how much product to load onto your eyeliner brush and how firmly to press in order to achieve a constant, steady line. I thought this was a fluke and did the right eye. Lots of people also wear mascara without eyeliner. This long-wearing, no-smudge eyeliner has a flexible tip that makes it easy to apply. However, not all eyeliners are the same. One of my favorite looks to do with this liner is honestly a cat eye because it’s foolproof and the perfect solution for when i am running late and do not have time for a full eyeshadow look. Of course, you should also make sure the color the eyeliner produces is vibrant and rich. Yellow eyeliner used to create a star on the side of rico’s face? I have tried magnetic eyelashes in the past (The ones that snap together over your real eyelashes, you know, the ones that online videos make it seem effortless to apply but that is not the case at all)! I have deep-set eyes that eat eyeliner for breakfast. Microliner is wonderful for lining the waterline if you have small eyes or creating a very small and defined …


Missha, Bold Effect, Pen Liner, True Black, 0.4 g

$6.00

There also seems to be a weight to each item that makes the makeup feel luxurious, in my opinion. Makeup wearers no longer have to choose between the ease of application in an eye pencil and the smooth feel of liquid eyeliner. A beauty adviser provides product advice based on the client’s skin care and makeup requirements. I have a process for doing my eye brows and this is the most important and first step. Lipsticks, liquid foundations, and other liquid cosmetics, as well as compressed makeups such as eye shadow and blush in compacts, are often called mineral makeup if they have the same primary ingredients as dry mineral makeups. Korean makeup is the perfect way to create a little illusion, and the cosmetics you see here can create every trick in the book. Update 9/17: Haus labs, the first makeup line from lady gaga, is now available to shop on amazon. The highly pigmented formula of this pencil eyeliner delivers a rich and intense colors. Eyelux mesmerizing eyeshadow is formulated to be extra smooth and silky in a mix of matte, satin and metal finishes. Although modern makeup has been traditionally used mainly by women, an increasing number of men are using cosmetics usually…


Wet n Wild, MegaLiner Liquid Eyeliner, Electric Purple, 0.12 fl oz (3.5 ml)

$3.00

It is easy to apply and can be used as both eyeliner and eyeshadow. The creamy eyeliner glides on comfortably with foolproof precision to create customizable eye definition. I just have really big eyes (And thus really big eyelids), so i find drawing a good cat eye impossibly hard. After reviewing dozens of products, the maybelline eyestudio master precise all day liquid eyeliner makeup stood out to us as the best. Some people might also use it on the bottom eyelid, though you will be hard pressed to find a style that uses eyeliner on only the bottom lid. No matter what look you have in mind, you can create it with one of these eyeliners. This eyeliner really does live up to the hype, and i was able to create my ideal cat eye in one stroke, which never ever happens.


L’Oreal, Telescopic Control Tip Liquid Eyeliner, Waterproof, 800 Black, .08 fl oz (2.45 ml)

$7.40

There are some reports that the small, plastic insert that prevents too much liquid eyeliner from covering the brush has a tendency to break. A lot of them crease and smudge easily, a nightmare scenario for anyone trying to master a fierce cat eye. Some people might also use it on the bottom eyelid, though you will be hard pressed to find a style that uses eyeliner on only the bottom lid. A few, like the nyx collection noir liquid black liner, literally disappeared before our eyes, while others like the marc jacobs highliner stayed as sharp and defined as if nothing had happened at all. It requires using a special eyeliner brush (An element we did not test for, though we have a couple recommendations in the our picks section), and that brush needs to be loaded up with product, and then wiped down or washed after your eyeliner is applied. A waterproof and long lasting pencil eyeliner with a smooth and soft application. While we found the actual eyeliner product in these items lacking, we will be keeping an eye out for application innovations that make getting graphic looks easier. Some come with a brush, but that does not necessarily mean it’s good (The companies are in the busin…


Covergirl, Ink it! All-Day Pencil Eyeliner, 230 Black Ink, .012 oz (0.35 g)

$6.40

The last thing you want is a dull, pale eyeliner. The ultimate list of the best eyeliners out in the market. I have used maybelline expertwear in black for years for eyebrows and sometimes as eyeliner, but hard to find in stores now. The uz eye opening liner checks this box with it’s thin painter’s brush-like tip that glides along with lids with ease. Depending on your requirement and preference, there are various kinds of eyeliners that you can choose from. It’s a go-to item in everyone’s makeup bag, and there is no shortage of options out there (Take a quick trip to the drugstore beauty aisle and you will see what we mean) but finding the best formulas is no easy feat. Should i wear eyeliner on the top or bottom? Pencil is the easiest of the three eyeliner formats to use and gives you good control over the quality of line, especially if you keep it well-sharpened. We reviewed dozens of eyeliners to help you choose the best of the best. That being said, it is fairly easy to take it off with some makeup remover. I always look to glossier when it comes time to stock my everyday makeup bag. I’m not a liquid eyeliner kind of person, though i really admire the look. To prevent aller…